- Open Access
HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein signatures that correlate with the development of cross-reactive neutralizing activity
Retrovirology volume 10, Article number: 102 (2013)
Current HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein (Env) vaccines are unable to induce cross-reactive neutralizing antibodies. However, such antibodies are elicited in 10-30% of HIV-1 infected individuals, but it is unknown why these antibodies are induced in some individuals and not in others. We hypothesized that the Envs of early HIV-1 variants in individuals who develop cross-reactive neutralizing activity (CrNA) might have unique characteristics that support the induction of CrNA.
We retrospectively generated and analyzed env sequences of early HIV-1 clonal variants from 31 individuals with diverse levels of CrNA 2–4 years post-seroconversion. These sequences revealed a number of Env signatures that coincided with CrNA development. These included a statistically shorter variable region 1 and a lower probability of glycosylation as implied by a high ratio of NXS versus NXT glycosylation motifs. Furthermore, lower probability of glycosylation at position 332, which is involved in the epitopes of many broadly reactive neutralizing antibodies, was associated with the induction of CrNA. Finally, Sequence Harmony identified a number of amino acid changes associated with the development of CrNA. These residues mapped to various Env subdomains, but in particular to the first and fourth variable region as well as the underlying α2 helix of the third constant region.
These findings imply that the development of CrNA might depend on specific characteristics of early Env. Env signatures that correlate with the induction of CrNA might be relevant for the design of effective HIV-1 vaccines.
The identification of the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1), as the causative agent of the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS), initiated a long-term but as of yet unsuccessful search for an effective and safe HIV-1 vaccine. Ideally a vaccine should elicit both humoral and cellular immunity . In particular the induction of cross-reactive neutralizing activity (CrNA) that is capable of neutralizing HIV-1 variants from different subtypes is appealing. Unfortunately, this has shown to be a difficult hurdle, and none of the vaccine candidates tested to date have been able to induce this type of humoral immunity [2–4]. The moderate efficacy against acquisition of infection in the RV144 vaccine trial , in which V1V2 IgG antibodies correlated inversely with the rate of infection , has lead to optimism in the HIV-1 vaccine field. In this trial, only very low titer, tier 1 neutralizing antibodies (NAbs) were detected and efficacy may improve with a vaccine that is capable of eliciting a cross-reactive neutralizing humoral immune response.
The HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein complex (Env) mediates entry into host cells and is the sole target for NAbs [7, 8]. A functional Env consists of heterotrimers of three gp120 subunits, non-covalently linked to three gp41 molecules that anchor the Env spike in the viral membrane. Gp120 has five conserved (C1-C5) and five variable regions (V1-V5) [9, 10]. The conserved regions form the core of the protein and are crucial for binding to the CD4-receptor on target cells [11–13]. The variable regions are highly diverse in sequence as a consequence of high replication rates, recombination, deletions, insertions and mutations . Gp120 and gp41 contain 20–35 and 3–5 potential N-linked glycosylation sites (PNGS), respectively. N-linked glycans compose approximately half of the molecular mass of gp120  and are required for correct protein folding, binding to lectin receptors on immune cells, as well as for immune evasion [16–20].
Within weeks to months after primary infection, HIV-1 Env specific antibodies appear  that are generally limited in their neutralizing activity and restricted to early autologous viruses [22–25]. The first antibodies are directed against gp41, predominantly to the immunodominant epitope, followed by non-NAbs against gp120, which in clade B-infected individuals often target the V3 region . Subsequently, weakly neutralizing V3 antibodies capable of neutralizing heterologous tier 1 HIV-1 isolates appear  followed by NAbs with other epitope specificities from which the virus rapidly escapes through sequence changes in the variable loops and an increasing number of PNGS. Specifically, an increase in length and number of PNGS of the V1V2 region plays a role in HIV-1 resistance to NAbs [22, 28–32].
Within 2–4 years post-seroconversion (post-SC), 10-30% of the HIV-1 infected individuals develop CrNA [33–40], which is directed against conserved epitopes such as the CD4-binding site (CD4BS), the membrane proximal region (MPER) in gp41 and glycan dependent epitopes that often include the glycans at positions 160 or 332 [41, 42]. Over the years, a number of broadly reactive neutralizing monoclonal antibodies (bNAbs) have been isolated from HIV-infected individuals with CrNA. These antibodies show broad and potent activity against different HIV-1 subtypes. As HIV-1 can rapidly escape from autologous humoral immunity with high levels of CrNA [25, 34], this immune response is not associated with prolonged asymptomatic survival of the individuals that make them [8, 21, 25, 36, 43, 44]. Nonetheless, bNAbs can protect non-human primates against viral challenge in passive immunization studies [45–49], which supports the idea that an HIV-1 vaccine that elicits CrNA could be effective against HIV-1 acquisition in humans.
BNAbs delineate sites of vulnerability on the Env spike. These sites can be divided into four bNAb epitope clusters located at different positions on the Env trimer [50–53]. Three epitope clusters are located on gp120, and one on gp41. The first epitope cluster is the CD4BS, which is the epitope for multiple bNAbs such as b12, VRC01, VRC-PG04, NIH45–46 and 3BNC117 [54–58]. The more recently discovered PGT121-130 and PGT135 bNAbs, as well as 2G12, target the outer domain on gp120 and are N332 glycan dependent [52, 59–63]. BNAbs PG9, PG16, PGT145 and CH01-CH04 target conserved epitopes within V1V2 that are expressed on trimeric Env [52, 53, 64–66]. Preferential binding of PG9 to the quaternary structure of trimeric Env could be explained by its binding to an epitope at the apex of the trimer that constitutes elements from two protomers . PG9, PG16 and PGT145 neutralization is dependent on the presence of glycans, especially at position N160 [64, 68]. One epitope cluster is located in the MPER of gp41, which contains the binding sites for 2F5, 4E10 and 10E8 [69–72].
The extensive glycosylation of gp120, amounting to ~50% of its molecular weight, was long thought to contribute to an immunologically “silent face” and serve as a “glycan shield” [8, 73]. The recent identification of many glycan-dependent bNAbs shows that the silent face may not be so immunologically silent after all, and that this shield can be penetrated and/or used by bNAbs. The epitope cluster on gp120 which is targeted by the bNAbs PGT121-130, PGT135 and 2G12 [60–62, 67, 74], requires a specific glycan at position 332, although there is a difference in how the different bNAbs approach this glycan. In addition, neutralization activity in serum of infected humans and macaques, which developed CrNA, is dependent on recognition of the epitope involving this glycan at position 332 [36, 75, 76]. Interestingly, Moore et al. recently showed that the 332 glycan was absent on the Env of early viruses from two clade C infected individuals but emerged as a means of escape from autologous neutralizing responses, thereby creating 332 glycan-dependent bNAb epitopes . For these reasons it seems that the glycosylation at position 332 plays a substantial role in the development of CrNA.
Although the existence of bNAbs in natural infection is testimony that the native Env spike can elicit bNAbs, it remains unknown why this occurs in only 10-30% of HIV-1 infected individuals. Here, we hypothesized that specific properties of early Envs could contribute to the development of CrNA. Information on such properties would obviously be valuable for vaccine design aimed at generating similar CrNA . To test our hypothesis, we retrospectively examined env sequences from early HIV-1 clonal variants in clade B infected individuals that developed diverse levels of CrNA later on during infection. We found that CrNA development correlated with early HIV-1 variants with shorter V1 regions, lower probability of glycosylation, and specific amino acid usage. These properties might open up avenues for vaccine design.
Short V1 sequences correlate with the development of cross-reactive neutralizing activity
To study Env determinants that may influence the induction of CrNA, we retrospectively generated env sequences from early HIV-1 variants in 31 individuals who at 2–4 years post-SC had diverse levels of CrNA in their serum (Figure 1) [35, 79]. We chose this experimental setup because contemporaneous viruses usually already have escaped from CrNA [25, 34] and early viruses are proposed to be a major determinant for the induction of CrNA . The individuals were matched for time between SC and CrNA measurement, time between SC and clonal virus isolation, CD4+ T cells/μl blood at set-point and viral load at set-point (Additional file 1: Figure S1). Data on HIV-1 neutralizing activity in serum were available from previous studies (n = 292) [35, 40, 79]. In short; sera were tested by Monogram Biosciences  for cross-reactive neutralizing activity in a pseudovirus assay involving six tier two viruses with Envs from primary isolates of HIV-1 subtypes A (94UG103), B (92BR020 and JRCSF), C (93IN905 and MGRM-C-026) and CRF01_AE (92TH021). This six viral panel covered 93% of the variation in neutralization of a larger pseudovirus panel (n = 15) . It has been shown that classification of CrNA in sera, as determined on this six virus panel, was highly correlated with CrNA determination on a larger 23 virus panel . The geometric mean IC50 titers in the sera of the selected individuals against a panel of 6 HIV-1 variants varied from 20 to 297; with an average of 98 (see Table 1 for details). Phylogenetic analysis of all sequences, using either neighbour-joining or maximum-likelihood methods, revealed clustering of sequences per individual, excluding contamination, but, clustering of HIV-1 Env sequences from individuals with similar geometric mean IC50 titer was not observed (Additional file 2: Figure S2). We observed that the geometric mean IC50 titer in serum correlated weakly with the mean length of V1 ((Figure 2B, r = −0.36; p = 0.049) but not with overall mean gp160 length (Figure 2A), nor with the total length of either the variable or the conserved regions (data not shown, r = −0.21; p = 0.25 and r = −0.052; p = 0.80, respectively).
Lower probability of overall glycosylation correlates with the induction of cross-reactive neutralizing activity
We did not observe a correlation between the geometric mean IC50 titer in serum, and the mean total number of PNGS in gp160 (Figure 2C) or the mean number of PNGS in the individuals variable or constant regions (data not shown). It has been shown that NXT motifs have a two to three times higher probability of becoming glycosylated than NXS motifs [82, 83]. The total number of PNGS may therefore not entirely reflect the actual extent of glycosylation of a given Env molecule. Interestingly, the mean number of NXS acceptor motifs relative to the mean total number of PNGS correlated positively with the geometric mean IC50 titer in serum (Figure 2D, r = 0.41; p = 0.037), while the opposite was true for the mean number of NXT acceptor motifs relative to the mean total number of PNGS. Thus, a higher relative number of NXS over NXT motifs, i.e. less probability of glycosylation was associated with the development of CrNA. However, we note that we cannot make statements on the actual glycosylation of individual NXS and NXT motifs.
Lower probability of glycosylation at position 332 correlates with the induction of cross-reactive neutralizing activity
We noted that the glycosylation motif at position 332, which is important for a number of bNAb epitopes [52, 59–62, 74], is always of the NXS type, and may thus not always be occupied by a glycan. In particular when the acceptor motif is NXS, the amino acid at position X is also important for determining the probability of glycosylation . In all our sequences, the second position was occupied by either a leucine or an isoleucine. We found that individuals who developed CrNA had significantly more often an NLS motif at position 332, while individuals who did not develop CrNA had more frequently an NIS motif (Figure 3A, p = 0.032). Studies with rabies virus glycoprotein showed that an NLS motif has a two times lower probability of becoming glycosylated compared to an NIS motif , which might imply that a lower probability of N-glycan attachment to N332 is associated with the development of CrNA. There is no straightforward way to directly assess glycan occupancy of position 332 on virus isolates, but we can study this indirectly by investigating the neutralization sensitivity to bNAbs that are dependent on the presence of a glycan at position 332, such as 2G12 and PGT126. Thus, we tested the sensitivity of the viruses from our infected individuals against 2G12 and PGT126, and divided them into two groups, for the presence of NLS or NIS at position 332. For 2G12 we excluded viruses that lacked one or more of the essential 2G12 glycans 295, 332, 386 or 392 [61, 62, 85] (i.e. the selected viruses should in theory all be sensitive to 2G12). We defined resistance as >50% infectivity at the highest concentration of bNAb (25 μg/ml and 5 μg/ml for 2G12 and PGT126, respectively; Figure 3B&C). We found that 7 out of 21 viruses (33%) with an NLS motif were resistant to 2G12, while only 2 of 14 viruses (14%) with an NIS motif were resistant (Figure 3B). Furthermore, we found that 4 out of 30 viruses (13%) with an NLS motif were resistant to PGT126, while none of the viruses with an NIS motif were resistant (Figure 3C). All NLS containing viruses that were resistant to PGT126 were also resistant to 2G12. Although these differences did not reach statistical significance they are consistent with a lower probability of glycosylation of NLS motifs, of which the presence is associated with the development with CrNA.
Sequence Harmony identifies specific amino acids that correlate with the induction of cross-reactive neutralizing activity
The Sequence Harmony (SH) method ( and http://www.ibi.vu.nl/programs/seqharmwww) was used to identify amino acid differences in Env between individuals who developed CrNA and who did not (Table 2). Low SH-scores indicate positions where the amino acid composition is different between the two groups; a score of 0 indicates that the amino acids at a given position are completely different between both groups, while the maximum score of 1 indicates that the amino acid compositions are indistinguishable. In addition, an empirical Z-score is calculated, reflecting the significance of the SH score obtained based on 100 random shuffling events of the sequences between the two groups. The SH analysis yielded 39 sites with a SH score below the defined cut-off values, indicating differences in amino-acids present at these sites between the CrNA and non-CrNA groups, all with high (negative) Z-scores indicating high significance (Table 2). A phylogenetic analysis showed the absence of sequence group clustering (Additional file 2: Figure S2), excluding spurious findings based on phylogeny. Individual sequences were weighted in the calculation of the SH-scores, such that each individual had equal weight (see Methods for details). For comparison, we repeated the analysis with a single consensus sequence per individual. This yielded essentially identical scores (the correlation between SH-scores and Z-scores is both r = 0.98, and p < 0.0001), but less detailed information on the specific amino acid changes (Additional file 3: Table S1 and Additional file 4: Figure S3). For the variable domains we used a cutoff of SH <0.7 and for the conserved domains a more relaxed cutoff of SH <0.85. This extended (higher) cut-off is necessary to find small differences within the conserved regions that have an overall higher sequence similarity. 22 sites were located in the variable regions, including 1 distinct site with the maximal score of 0.0 located in the V1 region which also contains 10 other sites scoring below 0.7 (z-scores ranging from −8 to −69). In the multiple sequence alignment, 6 insertions occur within the V1 region between positions 140 and 141 and are in agreement with the observed longer V1 region in individuals who did not develop CrNA (Figure 2B). One site is located in the V3 region (position 322), 8 sites in V4 (396, 399, 403–407 and 412) and 2 sites in V5 (461 and 464) all with z-scores ranging from −9 to −35. As conserved regions show inherently higher sequence conservation than the variable regions, a less strict cut-off of SH <0.85 was used. This resulted in the selection of 17 sites: 6 in the C1 region (32, 33, 85, 87, 97 and 130), 3 in C2 (268, 271 and 275), 6 in C3 (333, 336, 337, 343, 346 and 347), and 1 site in C4 (S440) (z-scores ranging from −3 to −16). The change at position 333 in C3 corresponds to the second position of the N332 glycosylation motif (see above). One additional relevant site was identified in the ectodomain of gp41 (621).
Structural mapping of the Sequence Harmony results reveals clustering of amino acids that are associated with the induction of CrNA
To better understand the impact of the results gained with SH, we mapped the positions that differed significantly on the three-dimensional structure of Env (Figure 4). A number of gp120 crystal structures were combined, as described in detail in the Methods section, to generate a structure of the Env spike that contains all gp120 residues (Figure 4A and B). Gp41 was not included as it contains only one position that was identified by SH (at position 621). Although this model may not be an accurate representation of the Env spike with correct positions and conformations of the variable domains, it is useful to visualize the residues identified by the SH analysis. The carbon trace is indicated in red, while the residues selected by the SH analysis are shown in yellow space filling. Mapping of the residues identified by SH on the 3D structure of Env reveals that the residues that differ between the Envs, which are derived from individuals that did develop and those that did not develop CrNA, cluster together in specific domains. First, a number of residues cluster in the V1 (Figure 4C and D). Second, a large cluster includes a major portion of the V4 as well as part of the underlying C3. Looking into these positions in more detail it is evident that a number of C3-residues located on the side of the α2 helix that faces the V4 are different between the two sequence groups and those residues that differ in the V4 are all close to the α2 helix (Figure 4E and F). A third cluster of residues can be observed in the gp41-interactive domain, including residues in C1 and C2, although these residues are more scattered throughout the domain, compared to those in the first two clusters. It is also obvious that some large regions in the protein do not contain any changes, most notably the CD4BS and the V2. Only one change is present in the bridging sheet, and also only one in the V3. The residues identified by SH can be further subdivided into thirteen subclusters based on their proximity to each other (<9 Å; Additional file 5: Table S2).
The induction of cross-reactive neutralizing activity does not correlate with sensitivity to bNAbs
We tested whether the early HIV-1 variants from individuals who developed CrNA were more sensitive to neutralization by bNAbs covering all known epitope clusters (gp120 outer domain: 447-52D, 2G12, PGT121 and PGT126; CD4BS: b12 and VRC01; quaternary epitopes: PG9, PG16 and PGT145; MPER: 4E10 and 2F5). We did not observe that the viral variants of individuals who developed CrNA were more sensitive to neutralization by different bNAbs compared to viruses from individuals who did not develop CrNA (Figure 5). We also analyzed the neutralization data for each bNAb per individual and we observed that the neutralization pattern was not dependent on the level of CrNA (Additional file 6: Table S3). We next tested the sensitivity of these viruses to three different polyclonal HIVIg pools in which multiple epitope specificities should be present. Interestingly, early HIV-1 variants of individuals who developed CrNA showed a trend towards being more sensitive to neutralization by polyclonal HIVIg compared to early viruses from individuals who did not develop CrNA (Figure 5), which could be consistent with them displaying a more open Env structure. However, this was only statistically significant for one of the three HIVIg pools (p=0.037).
In the Amsterdam Cohort Studies on HIV infection and AIDS (ACS) of men who have sex with men (MSM) infected with HIV-1 subtype B, the prevalence of CrNA at 2–4 years post-SC is around 33% [40, 79]. This roughly corresponds to what has been found in other cohorts [33, 37–39]. In this study we aimed to identify differences in the properties of early Env proteins in 31 HIV-1 infected individuals in regard to the development of CrNA. We observed that a short V1 region and a lower probability of N-linked glycosylation at PNGS correlated with the development of CrNA later in infection. More specifically, a lower probability of glycosylation at position 332 was associated with the development of CrNA. However, we note that the studies on the glycosylation efficiency of NXS/T motifs have been performed with a non-HIV protein  and the probability of glycosylation is likely to be context dependent. We can, therefore, not make definitive statements on the actual glycosylation of individual viruses or groups. Although some of the observed associations were marginally significant, and require confirmation in independent studies, they are in line with the hypothesis that HIV-1 Envs from individuals who develop CrNA have a more open structure, which allows for increased accessibility of bNAb epitopes, and possibly more efficient induction of bNAbs. To confirm this hypothesis we conducted a neutralization assay with early HIV-1 clonal variants from only the individuals who did or did not develop CrNA and found that early viruses of individuals who developed CrNA were indeed more sensitive to neutralization by one polyclonal HIVIg sample (but not by two other HIVIg samples), although we were not able to map this to specific bNAb epitopes. We next used SH for a more detailed analysis of amino acid differences at specific positions in Env and their role in the induction of CrNA. This resulted in the identification of 39 Env residues which differed significantly between the two groups, based on defined SH-scores and z-scores. These residues showed a remarkable clustering in V1, C3-V4, and somewhat more diffusely in C1-C2. In addition, a few individual changes were observed: one in V3, one in C4, three in the V5, and one in the gp41 ectodomain. Strikingly, we did not find any residues in the V2 domain, in the CD4BS, or in the triple layered structure that translates CD4 induced conformational changes to gp41 . We note that the differences we found might be specific for individuals who are infected with HIV-1 subtype B, and should be reproduced in other non-subtype B cohorts.
Our data revealed an inverse correlation between V1-length and the development of CrNA. Two previous studies have looked for Env signatures associated with the presence of CrNA, but these studies used contemporaneous samples for Env analysis and assessment of neutralization breadth and potency, and it is not likely that the contemporaneous Envs represent the Envs that induced the CrNA [89, 90]. Nevertheless, in the first study, involving clade C infected individuals, short V1V2 domains correlated with the presence of CrNA, but the V1 and V2 were not studied separately . In the second study, involving individuals infected with different clades, short V2 and short V5 regions correlated with the presence of CrNA in the sera . Again, the caveat in these studies is that the Env sequences and sera were derived from the same time point during chronic infection; therefore it cannot be excluded that the Env characteristics observed were a consequence rather than a cause of the CrNA in serum, due to viral escape from the CrNA. In contrast, we studied the Envs of early viruses (median 5 months post-SC), before the presence of CrNA, and related the characteristics to the development of CrNA later in infection. It is arguably more likely that the observed Env signatures we identified indeed contributed to the shaping of the CrNA. Although other choices could have been made in the timing of our sampling, Moore et al. showed that transmitted/founder viruses raise autologous neutralization, which triggers the evolution of escape variants around month 6 (roughly around the same time as our sampling of env sequences), which in turn induce CrNA .
The SH-analysis confirmed a role for V1, but in addition to the deletions/insertions (at positions 141, 145 and 146) identified a number of other amino acid changes in V1 that were associated with the development of CrNA (at positions 134–140, 142 and 151). It has long been known that V1 and V2 are not absolutely required for function [10, 91], but that they play an important role in resistance to antibody neutralization [28, 31, 92–96]. On a population level the continuous neutralizing antibody-driven evolution of V1V2 during the pandemic appears to have resulted in the elongation and increased glycosylation of the V1V2 domains . It may therefore not come as a surprise that short V1 domains, with a specific amino acid composition, might affect the induction of CrNA. We note, however, that we found no residues in V2 that differed between the two groups. This could suggest that V1 length and composition are more important determining factors in the induction of CrNA than V2 length and composition, at least in our study population.
Previous studies indicated that the Envs from transmitted/founder HIV-1 variants contain fewer PNGS compared to Envs from viruses in chronic infection . The increase in number of PNGS coincides with a decreasing sensitivity to autologous neutralization and is proposed to be driven by the pressure of neutralizing antibodies [8, 22, 29, 30, 32, 99]. Furthermore, a reduced prevalence of CrNA in recently infected individuals compared to historic serum samples was associated with an increased number of PNGS in early Env sequences , suggesting that an increase in Env glycosylation over the course of the epidemic results in decreased induction of CrNA. Thus, an increased number of PNGS and a higher level of N-linked glycosylation could interfere with the induction of bNAbs, as these glycans may interfere with the binding of the B cell receptor to protein epitopes on Env. We did not observe a correlation with the absolute number of PNGS and the later presence of CrNA. However, we did observe that a lower probability of glycosylation at the PNGS in early HIV-1 variants was associated with CrNA presence later in infection. In previous Env sequence analyses, NXS and NXT PNGS motifs have always been treated equally, but NXS motifs are two to three times less likely to be glycosylated than NXT sequons [82, 83, 100]. Furthermore, when an NXS motif is present, the amino acid at the second position (the X) becomes highly relevant to determining the probability of glycosylation .
Zooming in on the NXS motif at position 332, the glycan which is critical for the binding of many known bNAbs [52, 59–62, 74] and which was associated with neutralization escape from early strain-specific antibodies and induction of CrNA , we observed a correlation between the amino acid at the second position and the presence of CrNA in serum later in infection. Thus, individuals who developed CrNA had significantly more often an NLS motif at position 332 compared to the individuals who did not develop CrNA who usually had an NIS motif. An NLS motif is two to three times less likely to be glycosylated compared to an NIS motif , implying that a lower chance of glycosylation at position 332 is associated with the development of CrNA. The probability of glycosylation and how HIV-1 might use this is unchartered territory and should be considered in other studies on the role of Env glycosylation in the co-evolution of the virus and the human immune system.
The association of a lower probability of glycosylation at position 332 with the induction of CrNA is counterintuitive when taking into account that many known bNAbs target this glycan [52, 59–62, 74]. There are two possible explanations for this paradox. First, this glycan is not often targeted in our study population and its absence increases the accessibility of other bNAb epitopes. Second, it is not the presence of this glycan per se that facilitates the induction of bNAbs to this site, but the emergence of this site during infection, possibly by means of escape from Abs that targeted the surrounding region in the absence of the glycan. This later scenario was indeed observed in individuals infected with clade C Env . The situation in our cohort was slightly different because the NXS motif at position 332 was present in all sequences, only the 2nd position changed over time. Furthermore the absence of the PNGS at position 332 in transmitted subtype C was accompanied by the presence of a PNGS at position 334 , while we never observed a PNGS motif at position 334 in our sequences. The impact of the PNGS at one of these two positions, and its relation with subtype specific transmission and antibody escape and induction, requires further study in different cohorts.
The SH analysis identified multiple amino acid positions in the C3 and V4 region that differed significantly between individuals that did or did not develop CrNA. Inspection of a quaternary model of the Env spike showed that many of these positions form two subclusters on the α2-helix in the C3 region (HXB2 numbering 335–352) and the V4 loop (Figure 4). One cluster contains 6 residues: 333 (which may modulate glycosylation at position 332; see above), 336 and 337 from C3, and 405–407 from V4. The second subcluster involves 5 residues: 343, 346 and 347 from C3, and 396 and 399 from V4. The C3 α2-helix interacts intimately with V4 and several of the differences found between individuals that did or did not develop CrNA might impact the interaction between the two subdomains. For example, it has been reported that interactions between residues 335 and 412, and 337 and 412 play an important role in the interaction of these two regions through electrostatic interactions . In our SH analyses, the Env sequences of individuals who developed CrNA, position 337 is often occupied by a negatively charged amino acid (E), whereas this position is mostly positively charged (K) in individuals that did not develop CrNA. A similar charge reversal is observed for position 343 which interacts with a number of V4 residues. Thus, changes in electrostatic interactions may influence the interaction between C3 and V4. Moreover, Kirchherr et al. identified three amino acid substitutions in the V4 region (393G, 397G, and 413N) that were associated with greater neutralization potency and breadth . Positions 393 and 397 are not observed in our SH-analysis but the neighboring residues, 396, 399 and 400, are. Position 413 is observed in our analysis and is part of a PNGS. Envs associated with CrNA more frequently had an Asparagine (N) at position 413. Gnanakaran et al. noted that the C3 α2-helix in clade B viruses is more hydrophobic and shielded from solvent by the V4 loop and glycosylation, while this domain is less hydrophobic, more exposed and more immunogenic in clade C viruses [101, 103]. Collectively these findings imply that the way in which the V4 folds over and covers the α2-helix of C3 might affect the induction of bNAbs .
The impact of other residues highlighted by the SH-analysis is somewhat unclear. Several hits were found in C1 and C2, including the β-sandwich domain which is known to interact with gp41 . The two sites identified by the SH-analysis at positions 461 and 463/464 in V5 are in close proximity to the CD4BS and might impact its accessibility. Two other sites which were significantly different between the two groups were at position 322 (V3) and 440 (C4). Position 322 is important for coreceptor usage, a conversion of a negatively charged residue to a positively charged residue is sufficient to switch a CCR5-using to a CXCR4-using virus [105, 106]. All the sequences we used were derived from CCR5-using viruses (data not shown), ruling out any bias caused by differences in coreceptor usage. Interestingly Rosen et al. showed a very strong covariation between residues 322 and 440 that is influenced by charge , pointing at a potential functional electrostatic interaction between these two residues. If and how these changes contribute to the development of CrNA remains to be further studied.
We had hypothesized that early HIV-1 variants from individuals who later developed CrNA might have an increased sensitivity to bNAbs. We used multiple bNAbs covering four well known target epitopes, namely CD4BS (b12 and VRC01), gp120 outer domain (447-52D, 2G12, PGT121 and PGT126), quaternary V1V2 (PG9, PG16 and PGT145) and MPER (2F5 and 4E10). However, we did not observe a significantly increased sensitivity to neutralization by these bNAbs. One could argue that this lack of correlation is due to the fact that individuals with CrNA are analyzed as a group without considering the epitope specificity of their CrNA. Each individual might have developed different specificities, blurring the results for individual bNAbs. Sera of 14 of our individuals were previously analyzed for binding to a panel of gp120 core proteins and their corresponding CD4BS knockout mutants and showed the presence of CD4BS directing Abs , but we could not find a correlation between the binding of CD4BS Abs and neutralization sensitivity of early clonal virus variants to VRC01. Another explanation could be that the specificities responsible for CrNA in our individuals may be different from those of the monoclonal bNAbs we tested. We did observe differences in sensitivity to the polyclonal HIVIg: clonal viral variants from individuals who developed CrNA showed a trend towards being more sensitive to HIVIg might be consistent with a more exposed Env structure. In summary, we cannot conclude which bNAb epitopes were immunogenic in our study population.
In a previous study we showed that the kinetics of CrNA development coincided with the kinetics of the induction of autologous neutralizing response, which was directed against viruses isolated early after SC . This suggests that the development of CrNA is driven by epitopes that are exposed on early viruses . Alternatively, CrNA may be induced by early (or slightly later) HIV-1 variants that have already escaped from the initial autologous neutralizing response . The latter observation is consistent with the hypothesis that HIV-1 escape variants selected by autologous NAbs, in turn, may elicit new NAbs with altered specificities that allow for broad reactivity . We studied early Env variants from a relatively wide time span (2 to 14 months after SC), therefore we cannot rule out or support one of the above hypotheses.
Currently known bNAbs take years to develop and show accumulation of many somatic mutations, suggesting that their development is driven by years of antigen exposure and possibly reflecting the continuous co-evolution of HIV-1 and the immune response directed to it [51, 52, 80, 108, 109]. This would suggest a more prominent role for viral evolution and diversity in the development of bNAbs. Consistent with this, greater Env diversity early in infection was associated with greater NAb breadth later in infection in a cohort of antiretroviral therapy naïve Kenyan women that were mostly infected with subtype A . In our present study, involving therapy naïve, subtype B infected MSM from the ACS; we did not observe a correlation between early Env diversity and the development of CrNA in serum (data not shown).
In summary, our current results show that sequence and structural characteristics of Env from early subtype B HIV-1 viruses may be associated with the development of CrNA in serum during infection. We observed that the presence of a short V1 and lower probability of glycosylation, specifically at position 332, were associated with the induction of CrNA. In addition, a number of amino acid changes that mostly clustered in V1 and C3-V4 correlated with the development of CrNA. Additional studies are needed to further clarify the role of these amino acids in the induction of CrNA, but the determinants for CrNA induction described here might facilitate the design of vaccines aimed at inducing bNAbs.
Individuals and viruses
Samples studied here were derived from participants of the ACS of MSM who were infected with HIV-1 subtype B. From all ACS participants, 292 were previously tested for the presence of CrNA in their sera at 2–4 years post-SC . Sera were tested for CrNA on a panel of 6 heterologous viruses from different subtypes  and ranked based on their geometric mean IC50 titer and on the number of viruses from the panel that were neutralized. For the present study we selected cohort participants for whom the date of seroconversion was known, who had a follow-up of at least 4 years, and were therapy naïve at the time of screening for CrNA. Moreover, clonal HIV-1 variants had to be available. These criteria were fulfilled by 32 individuals who seroconverted between 1984 and 1996 [35, 40, 79]. One of these individuals was defined as elite neutralizer, according to the definition of Simek et al.  with a geometric mean IC50 titer of 782. We excluded this individual from our study as it is the subject of other follow-up studies, leaving us with 31 individuals fulfilling our criteria (Table 1).
Clonal virus variants were previously obtained from co-cultures of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from HIV-1 infected individuals and 3-day phytohemagglutinin (PHA) stimulated PBMCs from healthy donors [111, 112]. As virus isolation by coculturing PBMCs from infected individuals with stimulated healthy donor PBMCs can result in selection of a variants that are more fit for replication in PBMCs in vitro, we used a protocol in which limiting numbers of PBMCs from infected individuals and stimulated healthy donor PBMCs were mixed in multiple parallel cultures. This allows for the isolation of multiple replication competent clonal variants, avoiding the outgrowth and loss of slowly replicating variants [111, 112]. Moreover, to prevent sequence changes during in vitro culture, the number of passages in PBMCs was kept to a minimum. This method yields in clonal sequences that are very similar to sequences derived from single genome amplification . The ACS are conducted in accordance with the ethical principles set out in the declaration of Helsinki, and written consent was obtained prior to data collection. The study was approved by the Academic Medical Center Institutional Medical Ethics Committee.
Gp160 sequence analysis
The HIV env genes from proviral-DNA isolated from PBMCs, that were infected in vitro with a single clonal HIV-1 variant, were PCR amplified and subsequently sequenced as described previously [114–116]. Complete gp160 sequences could be analyzed for 26 individuals, whereas only C1-V5 env sequences could be analyzed for individuals ACH19566, 19342, 18860, 18839 and 18829 (Table 1). Nucleotide sequences were aligned using ClustalW in the software package of BioEdit , and edited manually. The reference sequence HXB2 was included in the alignment to number each aligned residue according to the corresponding position in this reference. Genetic analyses were performed on gp160 sequences starting at nucleotide position 91, thereby excluding the Env signal peptide. The total length of the gp160 sequences and the separate regions were calculated by counting the number of amino acids. The number of PNGS and number of NXT or NXS motifs were identified using N-Glycosite  at the Los Alamos HIV database website (http://www.hiv.lanl.gov/content/sequence/GLYCOSITE/glycosite.html). Sequences with double PNGS were counted by N-Glycosite as followed: NNSS as +1 NXS motif, NNTT as +1 NXT sequon, and NN[TS][ST] as +1 NXT motif. A proline at the second position (site pattern NP[ST]) is strongly disfavored for glycosylation and therefore excluded as a PNGS. Net electrostatic charges of gp160 were calculated by counting all charged amino acid residues per sequence, where residues R and K counted as +1, H as +0.293, and D and E as −1. Intra-individual genetic diversity of the complete Env sequences generated from the earliest time point were analyzed for 23 individuals, using the Kimura-2 parameter model of evolution in the MEGA 4.1 software package (http://www.megasoftware.net).
A Maximum Likelihood (ML) tree was constructed with complete HIV-1 env gp160 sequences from 26 individuals with diverse levels of CrNA. The best-fit nucleotide substitution model (GTR+I+G), selected by hierarchical likelihood ratio test (hLTRs, Model Test 3.7  was implemented in the heuristic search for the best ML tree applying TBR branch-swapping algorithm using PAUP*4.0, starting with a Neighbor-Joining (NJ) tree constructed under the Hasegawa-Kishino-Yano (HKY85) model of evolution . The robustness of the NJ phylogeny was assessed by bootstrap analysis with 1,000 rounds of replication.
Neutralization sensitivity to known bNAbs and polyclonal HIVIg pools was tested in a PBMC based assay, for a minimum of one and a maximum of five clonal virus variants per individual. PBMCs were isolated from buffy coats obtained from healthy seronegative blood donors and cultured as described previously . The neutralization sensitivity was tested for the twelve individuals who developed CrNA and the nine individuals who did not develop CrNA. The individuals who developed CrNA were included in this group following the criteria of having a geometric mean IC50 titer ≥ 90 in serum and the ability to neutralize ≥ 5 viruses from the panel of six heterologous viruses in a pseudovirus assay developed by Monogram Biosciences. The panel consisted of six pseudoviruses with envelope sequences from primary isolates of HIV-1 subtypes A (94UG103), B (92BR020 and JRCSF), C (93IN905 and MGRM-C-026) and CRF01_AE (92TH021) . Individuals of whom the sera had a geometric mean IC50 titer ≤ 45 in serum and neutralized ≤ 2 viruses from the panel of 6 heterologous viruses were included in the group that did not develop CrNA (Table 1). In total eleven broadly reactive neutralizing monoclonal antibodies (bNAbs) were tested; IgG1 b12 (kindly provided by NIBSC; EVA3065), 2G12, 2F5 and 4E10 (kindly provided by NIBSC; ARP3277, EVA3063, ARP3239), PG9 and PG16 (AIDS reagent program #12149 and 12150), VRC01 (AIDS reagent program #12033), 447-52D (kindly provided by NIBSC; ARP3219)) and PGT121, PGT126 and PGT145 (kindly provided by IAVI NAC repository); and three pools of polyclonal HIVIg sera: pool 1 (AIDS reagent program #3957 lot. nr. 12–100158), pool 2 (AIDS reagent program #3957 lot. nr. 14–120074), and pool 3 (AIDS reagent program #3957 lot. nr. 11–098130; NABI lot. nr. IHV-50-111 and lot. nr. IHV-250-114 ). HIVIg is a pool of concentrated antibodies from the blood from HIV-positive asymptomatic persons with high levels of HIV-1 specific antibodies.
From each virus isolate, a final inoculum of 20 50% tissue culture infective doses (TCID50) was incubated for 1 h at 37°C with each specific monoclonal antibody in threefold serial dilution. The starting dilution was 25 μg/ml for b12, 2G12, 2F5, 4E10 and 447-52D, and 5 μg/ml for PG9, PG16, VRC01, PGT121, PGT126 and PGT145. To test the neutralization sensitivity of the virus clones against HIVIg a final inoculum of 20 TCID50 was incubated for 1 h at 37°C in threefold serial dilution with a starting dilution of 1500 μg/ml. Subsequently, 105 PHA-stimulated PBMCs, derived from healthy blood donors, were added to the mixture. After incubation with HIVIg an additional washing step was performed with phosphate-buffered saline after 4 h of incubation at 37°C. On days 7 and 11, virus production in culture supernatants was analyzed with a p24 antigen capture enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay . The percent neutralization was calculated by determining the reduction in p24 production in the presence of the bNAbs or HIVIg compared to the cultures with virus only. When possible, IC50s were determined by linear regression. When the analyses required the assignment of one IC50 value per individual, we took the median of the IC50 values of the individual virus clones. For calculations, viruses with IC50 values below the lowest dilution or above the highest dilution were assigned the lowest or highest dilution value, respectively.
Statistical analyses on the gp160 sequence and the neutralization data were performed using Graphpad Prism v5.01. Differences between sequences (length, number of PNGS, NXS or NXT motifs and net electrostatic charge) were compared using a Spearman correlation test, with the geometric mean IC50 titer across the six heterologous viral panel as the absolute x-value. Differences and correlations were considered statistically significant when P values were ≤ 0.05. In cases of normal distribution of the data we used the unpaired t-test (for example to compare the mean neutralization titers for the eleven known bNAbs and polyclonal HIVIg pools between individuals that did or did not develop CrNA). When neutralization titers were not distributed normally, a Mann–Whitney test was performed to compare the two groups. For each individual, the median IC50 values of each bNAb or HIVIg were used. Difference in NIS vs. NLS glycosylation at position 332 and its correlation with the presence of CrNA was compared using a Fischer’s exact test.
Multiple sequence alignment for Sequence Harmony
A multiple sequence alignment was performed on 91 Env sequences from 21 individuals, starting at nucleotide position 91, which excludes the Env signal peptide, with a minimum of one and a maximum of eleven sequences per individual. In total we obtained 58 sequences from twelve individuals who developed CrNA and 33 sequences from nine individuals that did not develop CrNA (Table 1). In order to create a Multiple Sequence Alignment of sufficient consistency in the variable regions, three of the most widely used tools, Praline, Muscle and Clustal [124–126], were used with a range of settings (different Pam/Blosum matrices, different gap open and gap extend penalties) and evaluated. None gave completely satisfactory results, so the final alignment was based on Praline with global pre-profiling and default settings. The variable regions were extensively adjusted manually using the Jalview alignment viewer and editor , by optimizing the alignment of sequence patterns such as the NXS/T glycosylation sites and guided by the conservation scores reported by Jalview, which are based on the conservation of physicochemical properties, without penalizing the introduction or elongation of gaps (Additional file 7: Figure S4).
Comparison of viral sequences with Sequence Harmony
The Sequence Harmony (SH) method ( and http://www.ibi.vu.nl/programs/seqharmwww) was used to analyze amino acid differences between the env sequences of the twelve individuals who developed CrNA and the nine individuals who did not develop CrNA (Table 2). The SH algorithm is an entropy-based method, which detects positions within an alignment that display compositional differences in related protein sequences divided in two groups, and might therefore be linked to functional differences. In addition, an empirical Z-score is calculated, reflecting the significance of the SH-score obtained based on 100 random shuffling events of the sequences between the two groups. For details see reference  and the online documentation on the web server (http://www.ibi.vu.nl/programs/seqharmwww). SH measures the overlap in distribution of amino acid types between two subgroups (A and B; in this case env sequences obtained from individuals who developed CrNA and individuals who did not) at a certain position (i) in the sequence alignment as follows:
where indicates the observed frequency in group A for amino acid type x at position i in the sequence, and analogously for amino acid frequencies observed in group B sequences. The final SH score is calculated by SH i = ½ ( SH i A/B + SH i B/A ). Therefore, an SH score of 0 indicates amino acid positions that are specific for one of the sequence groups, whereas an SH score of 1 indicates a complete overlap at this amino acid position between the two groups. In our dataset, the number of sequences included per individual varies from 1 to 11, which makes the analysis biased towards individuals with larger numbers of sequences included. To adjust for this bias we extended the SH method by including a weight for each sequence. We assigned a weight w=1/N p to each sequence as the inverse of the number of sequences N p included for individual p. Each individual will therefore have the same impact on the total score in each group. Cut-off scores were set as SH<0.7 for the residues in the variable regions and <0.85 for residues in the conserved regions, i.e. a less strict selection in the conserved region to allow also small(er) differences to be detected. The lower (negative) the z-score, the less likely that the results were found by chance.
SH yielded a list of amino acid differences in Env between individuals who did developed CrNA and who did not, but structural analysis informs us on the location of these positions in the protein structure. A structure of the complete Env trimer is not available. In order to assist the inspection of the positions that were different between the two groups as identified by SH, we built a model that contained all gp120 domains. We started with the gp120 structure from 3JWD , because it contains the N- and C-termini of gp120. To this structure we added the V1V2 loops from 3U4E and using 1GCG  to obtain an overlap with the 3JWD structure; as well as the V3 and V4 regions from 2B4C . These structures were overlaid using the ‘super’ and ‘pair_fit’ functions of PyMol (The PyMOL Molecular Graphics System, Version 126.96.36.199 Schrödinger, LLC). No additional loop modeling was performed, so the actual conformation of the V1V2, V3 and the V4 regions as presented should be considered an arbitrary visualization of the residues identified by SH. Note that the glycans are absent from this model. The sites selected by the SH analysis (i.e., the residues scoring below the cut-off, as described above) were mapped on the three-dimensional structure of the resulting model using PyMol.
Availability of supporting data
The sequences supporting the results of this article are available in the GenBank repository [Genbank: EU743974-743976; EU743978-743979; HQ6444871-644872; JF910158-910162; JF910166; JF910176-910178; JF910181-910183; JF910188-910190, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/genbank].
Human immunodeficiency virus type-1
Acquired immunodeficiency syndrome
Cross-reactive neutralizing activity
Envelope glycoprotein complex
Potential N-linked glycosylation sites
Broadly reactive neutralizing monoclonal antibodies
Amsterdam Cohort Studies on HIV infection and AIDS
Men who have sex with men
Peripheral blood mononuclear cells
50% tissue culture infective doses.
Kim JH, Rerks-Ngarm S, Excler JL, Michael NL: HIV vaccines: lessons learned and the way forward. Curr Opin HIV AIDS. 2010, 5: 428-434.
Belshe RB, Graham BS, Keefer MC, Gorse GJ, Wright P, Dolin R, Matthews T, Weinhold K, Bolognesi DP, Sposto R, et al: Neutralizing antibodies to HIV-1 in seronegative volunteers immunized with recombinant gp120 from the MN strain of HIV-1. NIAID AIDS Vaccine Clinical Trials Network. JAMA. 1994, 272: 475-480.
Mascola JR, Snyder SW, Weislow OS, Belay SM, Belshe RB, Schwartz DH, Clements ML, Dolin R, Graham BS, Gorse GJ, et al: Immunization with envelope subunit vaccine products elicits neutralizing antibodies against laboratory-adapted but not primary isolates of human immunodeficiency virus type 1. J Infect Dis. 1996, 173: 340-348.
Pitisuttithum P, Berman PW, Phonrat B, Suntharasamai P, Raktham S, Srisuwanvilai LO, Hirunras K, Kitayaporn D, Kaewkangwal J, Migasena S, et al: Phase I/II study of a candidate vaccine designed against the B and E subtypes of HIV-1. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr. 2004, 37: 1160-1165.
Rerks-Ngarm S, Pitisuttithum P, Nitayaphan S, Kaewkungwal J, Chiu J, Paris R, Premsri N, Namwat C, de Souza M, Adams E, et al: Vaccination with ALVAC and AIDSVAX to Prevent HIV-1 Infection in Thailand. N Engl J Med. 2009, 361: 2209-2220.
Haynes BF, Gilbert PB, McElrath MJ, Zolla-Pazner S, Tomaras GD, Alam SM, Evans DT, Montefiori DC, Karnasuta C, Sutthent R, et al: Immune-correlates analysis of an HIV-1 vaccine efficacy trial. N Engl J Med. 2012, 366: 1275-1286.
Gelderblom HR, Hausmann EHS, Ozel M, Pauli G, Koch MA: Fine structure of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) and immunolocalization of structural proteins. Virology. 1987, 156: 171-176.
Wei X, Decker JM, Wang S, Hui H, Kappes JC, Wu X, Salazar-Gonzalez JF, Salazar MG, Kilby JM, Saag MS, et al: Antibody neutralization and escape by HIV-1. Nature. 2003, 422: 307-312.
Willey RL, Rutledge RA, Dias S, Folks T, Theodore T, Buckler CE, Martin MA: Identification of conserved and divergent domains within the envelope gene of the acquired immunodeficiency syndrome retrovirus. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1986, 83: 5038-5042.
Starcich BR, Hahn BH, Shaw GM, McNeely PD, Modrow S, Wolf H, Parks ES, Parks WP, Josephs SF, Gallo RC, et al: Identification and characterization of conserved and variable regions in the envelope gene of HTLV-III/LAV, the retrovirus of AIDS. Cell. 1986, 45: 637-648.
Cordonnier A, Montagnier L, Emerman M: Single amino-acid changes in HIV envelope affect viral tropism and receptor binding. Nature. 1989, 340: 571-574.
Kowalski M, Potz J, Basiripour L, Dorfman T, Goh WC, Terwilliger E, Dayton A, Rosen G, Haseltine WA, Sodroski J: Functional regions of the envelope glycoprotein of human immunodeficiency virus type I. Science. 1987, 237: 1351-1355.
Olshevsky U, Helseth E, Furman C, Li J, Haseltine W, Sodroski J: Identification of individual human immunodeficiency virus type 1 gp120 amino acids important for CD4 receptor binding. J Virol. 1990, 64: 5701-5707.
Shehu-Xhilaga M, Oelrichs RB: Basic HIV virology. HIV Management in Australasia. Edited by: Hoy J, Lewin S, Post J, Street A. 2009, Darlinghurst: Australasian Society for HIV Medicine, 9-18.
Allan JS, Coligan JE, Bariun F, et al: Major glycoprotein antigens that induce antibodies in AIDS patients are encoded by HTLV-III. Science. 1985, 228: 1091-1093.
Binley JM, Ban YE, Crooks ET, Eggink D, Osawa K, Schief WR, Sanders RW: Role of complex carbohydrates in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 infection and resistance to antibody neutralization. J Virol. 2010, 84: 5637-5655.
Geijtenbeek TB, Kwon DS, Torensma R, Van Vliet SJ, Van Duijnhoven GC, Middel J, Cornelissen IL, Nottet HS, KewalRamani VN, Littman DR, et al: DC-SIGN, a dendritic cell-specific HIV-1-binding protein that enhances trans-infection of T cells. Cell. 2000, 100: 491-494.
Montefiori DC, Robinson WE, Mitchell WM: Role of protein N-glycosylation in pathogenesis of human immunodeficiency virus type 1. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1988, 85: 9248-9252.
Reitter JN, Means RE, Desrosiers RC: A role for carbohydrates in immune evasion in AIDS. Nat Med. 1998, 4: 679-684.
Walker BD, Kowalski M, Goh WC, Kozarsky K, Krieger M, Rosen C, Rohrschneider L, Haseltine WA, Sodroski J: Inhibition of human immunodeficiency virus syncytium formation and virus replication by castanospermine. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 1987, 84: 8120-8124.
Aasa-Chapman MM, Cheney KM, Hue S, Forsman A, O'Farrell S, Pellegrino P, Williams I, McKnight A: In vivo emergence of HIV-1 highly sensitive to neutralizing antibodies. PLoS One. 2011, 6: e23961-
Bunnik EM, Pisas L, van Nuenen AC, Schuitemaker H: Autologous neutralizing humoral immunity and evolution of the viral envelope in the course of subtype B human immunodeficiency virus type 1 infection. J Virol. 2008, 82: 7932-7941.
Montefiori DC, Morris L, Ferrari G, Mascola JR: Neutralizing and other antiviral antibodies in HIV-1 infection and vaccination. Curr Opin HIV AIDS. 2007, 2: 169-176.
Richman DD, Wrin T, Little SJ, Petropoulos CJ: Rapid evolution of the neutralizing antibody response to HIV type 1 infection. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2003, 100: 4144-4149.
van Gils MJ, Bunnik EM, Burger JA, Jacob Y, Schweighardt B, Wrin T, Schuitemaker H: Rapid escape from preserved cross-reactive neutralizing humoral immunity without loss of viral fitness in HIV-1-infected progressors and long-term nonprogressors. J Virol. 2010, 84: 3576-3585.
Tomaras GD, Yates NL, Liu P, Qin L, Fouda GG, Chavez LL, Decamp AC, Parks RJ, Ashley VC, Lucas JT, et al: Initial B-cell responses to transmitted human immunodeficiency virus type 1: virion-binding immunoglobulin M (IgM) and IgG antibodies followed by plasma anti-gp41 antibodies with ineffective control of initial viremia. J Virol. 2008, 82: 12449-12463.
Davis KL, Gray ES, Moore PL, Decker JM, Salomon A, Montefiori DC, Graham BS, Keefer MC, Pinter A, Morris L, et al: High titer HIV-1 V3-specific antibodies with broad reactivity but low neutralizing potency in acute infection and following vaccination. Virology. 2009, 387: 414-426.
Cao J, Sullivan N, Desjardin E, Parolin C, Robinson J, Wyatt R, Sodroski J: Replication and neutralization of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 lacking the V1 and V2 variable loops of the gp120 envelope glycoprotein. J Virol. 1997, 71: 9808-9812.
Curlin ME, Zioni R, Hawes SE, Liu Y, Deng W, Gottlieb GS, Zhu T, Mullins JI: HIV-1 envelope subregion length variation during disease progression. PLoS Pathog. 2010, 6: e1001228-
Sagar M, Wu X, Lee S, Overbaugh J: Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 V1-V2 envelope loop sequences expand and add glycosylation sites over the course of infection, and these modifications affect antibody neutralization sensitivity. J Virol. 2006, 80: 9586-9598.
Stamatatos L, Cheng-Mayer C: An envelope modification that renders a primary, neutralization-resistant clade B human immunodeficiency virus type 1 isolate highly susceptible to neutralization by sera from other clades. J Virol. 1998, 72: 7840-7845.
van Gils MJ, Bunnik EM, Boeser-Nunnink BD, Burger JA, Terlouw-Klein M, Verwer N, Schuitemaker H: Longer V1V2 region with increased number of potential N-linked glycosylation sites in the HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein protects against HIV-specific neutralizing antibodies. J Virol. 2011, 85: 6986-6995.
Doria-Rose NA, Klein RM, Manion MM, O'Dell S, Phogat A, Chakrabarti B, Hallahan CW, Migueles SA, Wrammert J, Ahmed R, et al: Frequency and phenotype of human immunodeficiency virus envelope-specific B cells from patients with broadly cross-neutralizing antibodies. J Virol. 2009, 83: 188-199.
Euler Z, van den Kerkhof TL, van Gils MJ, Burger JA, Edo-Matas D, Phung P, Wrin T, Schuitemaker H: Longitudinal analysis of early HIV-1 specific neutralizing activity in an elite neutralizer and in five patients who developed cross-reactive neutralizing activity. J Virol. 2012, 86: 2045-2055.
Euler Z, van Gils MJ, Bunnik EM, Phung P, Schweighardt B, Wrin T, Schuitemaker H: Cross-reactive neutralizing humoral immunity does not protect from HIV type 1 disease progression. J Infect Dis. 2010, 201: 1045-1053.
Gray ES, Madiga MC, Hermanus T, Moore PL, Wibmer CK, Tumba NL, Werner L, Mlisana K, Sibeko S, Williamson C, et al: The neutralization breadth of HIV-1 develops incrementally over four years and is associated with CD4+ T cell decline and high viral load during acute infection. J Virol. 2011, 85: 4828-4840.
Mikell I, Sather DN, Kalams SA, Altfeld M, Alter G, Stamatatos L: Characteristics of the Earliest Cross-Neutralizing Antibody Response to HIV-1. PLoS Pathog. 2011, 7: e1001251-
Sather DN, Armann J, Ching LK, Mavrantoni A, Sellhorn G, Caldwell Z, Yu X, Wood B, Self S, Kalams S, et al: Factors associated with the development of cross-reactive neutralizing antibodies during human immunodeficiency virus type 1 infection. J Virol. 2009, 83: 757-769.
Simek MD, Rida W, Priddy FH, Pung P, Carrow E, Laufer DS, Lehrman JK, Boaz M, Tarragona-Fiol T, Miiro G, et al: HIV-1 Elite Neutralizers: Individuals with Broad and Potent Neutralizing Activity Identified Using a High Throughput Neutralization Assay Together with an Analytical Selection Algorithm. J Virol. 2009, 83: 7337-7348.
van Gils MJ, Euler Z, Schweighardt B, Wrin T, Schuitemaker H: Prevalence of cross-reactive HIV-1-neutralizing activity in HIV-1-infected patients with rapid or slow disease progression. AIDS. 2009, 23: 2405-2414.
Binley JM, Lybarger EA, Crooks ET, Seaman MS, Gray E, Davis KL, Decker JM, Wycuff D, Harris L, Hawkins N, et al: Profiling the specificity of neutralizing antibodies in a large panel of plasmas from patients chronically infected with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 subtypes B and C. J Virol. 2008, 82: 11651-11668.
Li Y, Migueles SA, Welcher B, Svehla K, Phogat A, Louder MK, Wu X, Shaw GM, Connors M, Wyatt RT, et al: Broad HIV-1 neutralization mediated by CD4-binding site antibodies. Nat Med. 2007, 13: 1032-1034.
Frost SD, Wrin T, Smith DM, Kosakovsky Pond SL, Liu Y, Paxinos E, Chappey C, Galovich J, Beauchaine J, Petropoulos CJ, et al: Neutralizing antibody responses drive the evolution of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 envelope during recent HIV infection. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2005, 102: 18514-18519.
Euler Z, Schuitemaker H: Cross-reactive broadly neutralizing antibodies: timing is everything. Front Immunol. 2012, 3: 215-
Hessell AJ, Poignard P, Hunter M, Hangartner L, Tehrani DM, Bleeker WK, Parren PW, Marx PA, Burton DR: Effective, low-titer antibody protection against low-dose repeated mucosal SHIV challenge in macaques. Nat Med. 2009, 15: 951-954.
Hessell AJ, Rakasz EG, Poignard P, Hangartner L, Landucci G, Forthal DN, Koff WC, Watkins DI, Burton DR: Broadly neutralizing human anti-HIV antibody 2G12 is effective in protection against mucosal SHIV challenge even at low serum neutralizing titers. PLoS Pathog. 2009, 5: e1000433-
Hessell AJ, Rakasz EG, Tehrani DM, Huber M, Weisgrau KL, Landucci G, Forthal DN, Koff WC, Poignard P, Watkins DI, et al: Broadly neutralizing monoclonal antibodies 2F5 and 4E10 directed against the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 gp41 membrane-proximal external region protect against mucosal challenge by simian-human immunodeficiency virus SHIVBa-L. J Virol. 2010, 84: 1302-1313.
Mascola JR, Lewis MG, Stiegler G, Harris D, VanCott TC, Hayes D, Louder MK, Brown CR, Sapan CV, Frankel SS, et al: Protection of Macaques against pathogenic simian/human immunodeficiency virus 89.6PD by passive transfer of neutralizing antibodies. J Virol. 1999, 73: 4009-4018.
Shibata R, Igarashi T, Haigwood N, Buckler-White A, Ogert R, Ross W, Willey R, Cho MW, Martin MA: Neutralizing antibody directed against the HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein can completely block HIV-1/SIV chimeric virus infection of macaque monkeys. Nat Med. 1999, 5: 204-210.
van Gils MJ, Sanders RW: Broadly neutralizing antibodies against HIV-1: templates for a vaccine. Virology. 2013, 435: 46-56.
Scheid JF, Mouquet H, Ueberheide B, Diskin R, Klein F, Olivera TY, Pietzsch J, Fenyo D, Abadir A, Velinzon K, et al: Sequence and Structural Convergence of Broad and Potent HIV Antibodies That Mimic CD4 Binding. Science. 2011, 333: 1633-1637.
Walker LM, Huber M, Doores KJ, Falkowska E, Pejchal R, Julien JP, Wang SK, Ramos A, Chan-Hui PY, Moyle M, et al: Broad neutralization coverage of HIV by multiple highly potent antibodies. Nature. 2011, 477: 466-470.
Wu X, Yang ZY, Li Y, Hogerkorp CM, Schief WR, Seaman MS, Zhou T, Schmidt SD, Wu L, Xu L, et al: Rational design of envelope identifies broadly neutralizing human monoclonal antibodies to HIV-1. Science. 2010, 329: 856-861.
Burton DR, Pyati J, Koduri R, Sharp SJ, Thornton GB, Parren PWH, Sawyer LSW, Hendry RM, Dunlop N, Nara PL, et al: Efficient neutralization of primary isolates of HIV-1 by a recombinant human monoclonal antibody. Science. 1994, 266: 1024-1027.
Corti D, Langedijk JP, Hinz A, Seaman MS, Vanzetta F, Fernandez-Rodriguez BM, Silacci C, Pinna D, Jarrossay D, Balla-Jhagjhoorsingh S, et al: Analysis of memory B cell responses and isolation of novel monoclonal antibodies with neutralizing breadth from HIV-1-infected individuals. PLoS One. 2010, 5: e8805-
Zhou T, Georgiev I, Wu X, Yang ZY, Dai K, Finzi A, Do KY, Scheid J, Shi W, Xu L, et al: Structural Basis for Broad and Potent Neutralization of HIV-1 by Antibody VRC01. Science. 2010, 329: 811-817.
Zhou T, Xu L, Dey B, Hessell AJ, Van RD, Xiang SH, Yang X, Zhang MY, Zwick MB, Arthos J, et al: Structural definition of a conserved neutralization epitope on HIV-1 gp120. Nature. 2007, 445: 732-737.
Diskin R, Scheid JF, Marcovecchio PM, West AP, Klein F, Gao H, Gnanapragasam PN, Abadir A, Seaman MS, Nussenzweig MC, et al: Increasing the potency and breadth of an HIV antibody by using structure-based rational design. Science. 2011, 334: 1289-1293.
Julien JP, Sok D, Khayat R, Lee JH, Doores KJ, Walker LM, Ramos A, Diwanji DC, Pejchal R, Cupo A, et al: Broadly Neutralizing Antibody PGT121 Allosterically Modulates CD4 Binding via Recognition of the HIV-1 gp120 V3 Base and Multiple Surrounding Glycans. PLoS Pathog. 2013, 9: e1003342-
Pejchal R, Doores KJ, Walker LM, Khayat R, Huang PS, Wang SK, Stanfield RL, Julien JP, Ramos A, Crispin M, et al: A potent and broad neutralizing antibody recognizes and penetrates the HIV glycan shield. Science. 2011, 334: 1097-1103.
Sanders RW, Venturi M, Schiffner L, Kalyanaraman R, Katinger H, Lloyd KO, Kwong PD, Moore JP: The Mannose-Dependent Epitope for Neutralizing Antibody 2G12 on Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Glycoprotein gp120. J Virol. 2002, 76: 7293-7305.
Scanlan CN, Pantophlet R, Wormald MR, Ollman Saphire E, Stanfield R, Wilson IA, Katinger H, Dwek RA, Rudd PM, Burton DR: The Broadly Neutralizing Anti-Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Antibody 2G12 Recognizes a Cluster of alfa1->2 Mannose Residues on the Outer Face of gp120. J Virol. 2002, 76: 7306-7321.
Trkola A, Purtscher M, Muster T, Ballaun C, Buchacher A, Sullivan N, Srinivasan K, Sodroski J, Moore JP, Katinger H: Human monoclonal antibody 2G12 defines a distinctive neutralization epitope on the gp120 glycoprotein of human immunodeficiency virus type 1. J Virol. 1996, 70: 1100-1108.
McLellan JS, Pancera M, Carrico C, Gorman J, Julien JP, Khayat R, Louder R, Pejchal R, Sastry M, Dai K, et al: Structure of HIV-1 gp120 V1/V2 domain with broadly neutralizing antibody PG9. Nature. 2011, 480: 336-343.
Walker LM, Phogat SK, Chan-Hui PY, Wagner D, Phung P, Goss JL, Wrin T, Simek MD, Fling S, Mitcham JL, et al: Broad and Potent Neutralizing Antibodies from an African Donor Reveal a New HIV-1 Vaccine Target. Science. 2009, 326: 285-289.
Bonsignori M, Hwang KK, Chen X, Tsao CY, Morris L, Gray E, Marshall DJ, Crump JA, Kapiga SH, Sam NE, et al: Analysis of a Clonal Lineage of HIV-1 Envelope V2/V3 Conformational Epitope-Specific Broadly Neutralizing Antibodies and Their Inferred Unmutated Common Ancestors. J Virol. 2011, 85: 9998-10009.
Julien JP, Lee JH, Cupo A, Murin CD, Derking R, Hoffenberg S, Caulfield MJ, King CR, Marozsan AJ, Klasse PJ, et al: Asymmetric recognition of the HIV-1 trimer by broadly neutralizing antibody PG9. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2013, 110: 4351-4356.
Doores KJ, Burton DR: Variable loop glycan dependency of the broad and potent HIV-1-neutralizing antibodies PG9 and PG16. J Virol. 2010, 84: 10510-10521.
Alam SM, Morelli M, Dennison SM, Liao HX, Zhang R, Xia SM, Rits-Volloch S, Sun L, Harrison SC, Haynes BF, et al: Role of HIV membrane in neutralization by two broadly neutralizing antibodies. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2009, 106: 20234-20239.
Muster T, Steindl F, Purtscher M, Trkola A, Klima A, Himmler G, Ruker F, Katinger H: A conserved neutralizing epitope on gp41 of human immunodeficiency virus type 1. J Virol. 1993, 67: 6642-6647.
Stiegler G, Kunert R, Purtscher M, Wolbank S, Voglauer R, Steindl F, Katinger H: A potent cross-clade neutralizing human monoclonal antibody against a novel epitope on gp41 of human immunodeficiency virus type 1. AIDS Res Hum Retroviruses. 2001, 17: 1757-1765.
Huang J, Ofek G, Laub L, Louder MK, Doria-Rose NA, Longo NS, Imamichi H, Bailer RT, Chakrabarti B, Sharma SK, et al: Broad and potent neutralization of HIV-1 by a gp41-specific human antibody. Nature. 2012, 491: 406-412.
Wyatt R, Kwong PD, Desjardins E, Sweet RW, Robinson J, Hendrickson WA, Sodroski J: The antigenic structure of the HIV gp120 envelope protein. Nature. 1998, 393: 705-711.
Kong L, Lee JH, Doores KJ, Murin CD, Julien JP, McBride R, Liu Y, Marozsan A, Cupo A, Klasse PJ, et al: Supersite of immune vulnerability on the glycosylated face of HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein gp120. Nat Struct Mol Biol. 2013, 20: 796-803.
Walker LM, Simek MD, Priddy F, Gach JS, Wagner D, et al: A limited number of antibody specificities mediate broad and potent serum neutralization in selected HIV-1 infected individuals. PLoS Pathog. 2010, 6 (8): e1001028-
Walker LM, Sok D, Nishimura Y, Donau O, Sadjadpour R, Gautam R, Shingai M, Pejchal R, Ramos A, Simek MD, et al: Rapid development of glycan-specific, broad, and potent anti-HIV-1 gp120 neutralizing antibodies in an R5 SIV/HIV chimeric virus infected macaque. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011, 108: 20125-20129.
Moore PL, Gray ES, Wibmer CK, Bhiman JN, Nonyane M, Sheward DJ, Hermanus T, Bajimaya S, Tumba NL, Abrahams MR, et al: Evolution of an HIV glycan-dependent broadly neutralizing antibody epitope through immune escape. Nat Med. 2012, 8: 1688-1692.
Walker BD, Burton DR: Toward an AIDS vaccine. Science. 2008, 320: 760-764.
Euler Z, van Gils MJ, Boeser-Nunnink BD, Schuitemaker H, van Manen D: Genome-wide association study on the development of cross-reactive neutralizing antibodies in HIV-1 infected individuals. PLoS One. 2013, 8: e54684-
Liao HX, Lynch R, Zhou T, Gao F, Alam SM, Boyd SD, Fire AZ, Roskin KM, Schramm CA, Zhang Z, et al: Co-evolution of a broadly neutralizing HIV-1 antibody and founder virus. Nature. 2013, 10: 469-476.
Binley JM, Wrin T, Korber B, Zwick MB, Wang M, Chappey C, Stiegler G, Kunert R, Zolla-Pazner S, Katinger H, et al: Comprehensive cross-clade neutralization analysis of a panel of anti-human immunodeficiency virus type 1 monoclonal antibodies. J Virol. 2004, 78: 13232-13252.
Gavel Y, von Heijne G: Sequence differences between glycosylated and non-glycosylated Asn-X-Thr/Ser acceptor sites: implications for protein engineering. Protein Eng. 1990, 3: 433-442.
Kaplan HA, Welply JK, Lennarz WJ: Oligosaccharyl transferase: the central enzyme in the pathway of glycoprotein assembly. Biochim Biophys Acta. 1987, 906: 161-173.
Shakin-Eshleman SH, Spitalnik SL, Kasturi L: The amino acid at the X position of an Asn-X-Ser sequon is an important determinant of N-linked core-glycosylation efficiency. J Biol Chem. 1996, 271: 6363-6366.
Sanders RW, Van AE, Nabatov AA, Liscaljet IM, Bontjer I, Eggink D, Melchers M, Busser E, Dankers MM, Groot F, et al: The carbohydrate at asparagine 386 on HIV-1 gp120 is not essential for protein folding and function but is involved in immune evasion. Retrovirology. 2008, 5: 10-
Pirovano W, Feenstra KA, Heringa J: Sequence comparison by sequence harmony identifies subtype-specific functional sites. Nucleic Acids Res. 2006, 34: 6540-6548.
Liu J, Bartesaghi A, Borgnia MJ, Sapiro G, Subramaniam S: Molecular architecture of native HIV-1 gp120 trimers. Nature. 2008, 455: 109-113.
Finzi A, Xiang SH, Pacheco B, Wang L, Haight J, Kassa A, Danek B, Pancera M, Kwong PD, Sodroski J: Topological layers in the HIV-1 gp120 inner domain regulate gp41 interaction and CD4-triggered conformational transitions. Mol Cell. 2010, 37: 656-667.
Gnanakaran S, Daniels MG, Bhattacharya T, Lapedes AS, Sethi A, Li M, Tang H, Greene K, Gao H, Haynes BF, et al: Genetic signatures in the envelope glycoproteins of HIV-1 that associate with broadly neutralizing antibodies. PLoS Comput Biol. 2010, 6: e1000955-
Rademeyer C, Moore PL, Taylor N, Martin DP, Choge IA, Gray ES, Sheppard HW, Gray C, Morris L, Williamson C: Genetic characteristics of HIV-1 subtype C envelopes inducing cross-neutralizing antibodies. Virology. 2007, 368: 172-181.
Wyatt R, Moore J, Accola M, Desjardin E, Robinson J, Sodroski J: Involvement of the V1/V2 variable loop structure in the exposure of Human Immunodeficiency Virus type 1 gp120 epitopes induced by receptor binding. J Virol. 1995, 69: 5723-5733.
Laakso MM, Lee FH, Haggarty B, Agrawal C, Nolan KM, Biscone M, Romano J, Jordan AP, Leslie GJ, Meissner EG, et al: V3 loop truncations in HIV-1 envelope impart resistance to coreceptor inhibitors and enhanced sensitivity to neutralizing antibodies. PLoS Pathog. 2007, 3: e117-
Liu L, Cimbro R, Lusso P, Berger EA: Intraprotomer masking of third variable loop (V3) epitopes by the first and second variable loops (V1V2) within the native HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein trimer. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2011, 108: 20148-20153.
Rusert P, Krarup A, Magnus C, Brandenberg OF, Weber J, Ehlert AK, Regoes RR, Gunthard HF, Trkola A: Interaction of the gp120 V1V2 loop with a neighboring gp120 unit shields the HIV envelope trimer against cross-neutralizing antibodies. J Exp Med. 2011, 208: 1419-1433.
Sanders RW, Schiffner L, Master A, Kajumo F, Guo Y, Dragic T, Moore JP, Binley JM: Variable-loop-deleted variants of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 envelope glycoprotein can be stabilized by an intermolecular disulfide bond between the gp120 and gp41 subunits. J Virol. 2000, 74: 5091-5100.
Saunders CJ, McCaffrey RA, Zharkikh I, Kraft Z, Malenbaum SE, Burke B, Cheng-Mayer C, Stamatatos L: The V1, V2, and V3 regions of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 envelope differentially affect the viral phenotype in an isolate-dependent manner. J Virol. 2005, 79: 9069-9080.
Bunnik EM, Euler Z, Welkers MR, Boeser-Nunnink BD, Grijsen ML, Prins JM, Schuitemaker H: Adaptation of HIV-1 envelope gp120 to humoral immunity at a population level. Nat Med. 2010, 16: 995-997.
Li M, Salazar-Gonzalez JF, Derdeyn CA, Morris L, Williamson C, Robinson JE, Decker JM, Li Y, Salazar MG, Polonis VR, et al: Genetic and Neutralization Properties of Acute and Early Subtype C Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 Molecular env Clones from Heterosexually Acquired Infections in Southern Africa. J Virol. 2006, Epub ahead of print:doi:10.1128/JVI.01730-06
Rong R, Bibollet-Ruche F, Mulenga J, Allen S, Blackwell JL, Derdeyn CA: Role of V1V2 and other human immunodeficiency virus type 1 envelope domains in resistance to autologous neutralization during clade C infection. J Virol. 2007, 81: 1350-1359.
Jenkins N, Parekh RB, James DC: Getting the glycosylation right: implications for the biotechnology industry. Nat Biotechnol. 1996, 14: 975-981.
Gnanakaran S, Lang D, Daniels M, Bhattacharya T, Derdeyn CA, Korber B: Clade-specific differences between human immunodeficiency virus type 1 clades B and C: diversity and correlations in C3-V4 regions of gp120. J Virol. 2007, 81: 4886-4891.
Kirchherr JL, Hamilton J, Lu X, Gnanakaran S, Muldoon M, Daniels M, Kasongo W, Chalwe V, Mulenga C, Mwananyanda L, et al: Identification of amino acid substitutions associated with neutralization phenotype in the human immunodeficiency virus type-1 subtype C gp120. Virology. 2011, 409: 163-174.
Moore PL, Ranchobe N, Lambson BE, Gray ES, Cave E, Abrahams MR, Bandawe G, Mlisana K, bdool Karim SS, Williamson C, et al: Limited neutralizing antibody specificities drive neutralization escape in early HIV-1 subtype C infection. PLoS Pathog. 2009, 5: e1000598-
Pancera M, Majeed S, Ban YE, Chen L, Huang CC, Kong L, Kwon YD, Stuckey J, Zhou T, Robinson JE, et al: Structure of HIV-1 gp120 with gp41-interactive region reveals layered envelope architecture and basis of conformational mobility. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2010, 107: 1166-1171.
De Jong JJ, De Ronde A, Keulen W, Tersmette M, Goudsmit J: Minimal requirements for the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 V3 domain to support the syncytium-inducing phenotype: analysis by single amino acid substitution. J Virol. 1992, 66: 6777-6780.
Fouchier RAM, Groenink M, Kootstra NA, Tersmette M, Huisman HG, Miedema F, Schuitemaker H: Phenotype-associated sequence variation in the third variable domain of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 gp120 molecule. J Virol. 1992, 66: 3183-3187.
Rosen O, Samson AO, Anglister J: Correlated mutations at gp120 positions 322 and 440: implications for gp120 structure. Proteins. 2008, 71: 1066-1070.
Moir S, Malaspina A, Fauci AS: Prospects for an HIV vaccine: leading B cells down the right path. Nat Struct Mol Biol. 2011, 18: 1317-1321.
Wu X, Zhou T, Zhu J, Zhang B, Georgiev I, Wang C, Chen X, Longo NS, Louder M, McKee K, et al: Focused Evolution of HIV-1 Neutralizing Antibodies Revealed by Structures and Deep Sequencing. Science. 2011, 333: 1593-1602.
Piantadosi A, Panteleeff D, Blish CA, Baeten JM, Jaoko W, McClelland RS, Overbaugh J: Breadth of neutralizing antibody response to human immunodeficiency virus type 1 is affected by factors early in infection but does not influence disease progression. J Virol. 2009, 83: 10269-10274.
Schuitemaker H, Koot M, Kootstra NA, Dercksen MW, de Goede RE, Van Steenwijk RP, Lange JM, Schattenkerk JK, Miedema F, Tersmette M: Biological phenotype of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 clones at different stages of infection: progression of disease is associated with a shift from monocytotropic to T-cell-tropic virus population. J Virol. 1992, 66: 1354-1360.
Van 't Wout AB, Schuitemaker H, Kootstra NA: Isolation and propagation of HIV-1 on peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Nat Protoc. 2008, 3: 363-370.
Edo-Matas D, van Gils MJ, Bowles EJ, Navis M, Rachinger A, Boeser-Nunnink B, Stewart-Jones GB, Kootstra NA, Wout AB, Schuitemaker H: Genetic composition of replication competent clonal HIV-1 variants isolated from peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC), HIV-1 proviral DNA from PBMC and HIV-1 RNA in serum in the course of HIV-1 infection. Virology. 2010, 405: 492-504.
Beaumont T, van Nuenen A, Broersen S, Blattner WA, Lukashov VV, Schuitemaker H: Reversal of HIV-1 IIIB towards a neutralization resistant phenotype in an accidentally infected laboratory worker with a progressive clinical course. J Virol. 2001, 75: 2246-2252.
Boom R, Sol CJA, Salimans MMM, Jansen CL, Wertheim-van Dillen PME, Van der Noordaa J: A rapid and simple method for purification of nucleic acids. J Clin Microbiol. 1991, 28: 495-503.
Quakkelaar ED, van Alphen FP, Boeser-Nunnink BD, van Nuenen AC, Pantophlet R, Schuitemaker H: Susceptibility of recently transmitted subtype B human immunodeficiency virus type 1 variants to broadly neutralizing antibodies. J Virol. 2007, 81: 8533-8542.
Hall TA: BioEdit: a user-friendly biological sequence alignment editor and analysis program for Windows 95/98/NT. Nucl Acids Symp Ser. 1999, 41: 95-98.
Zhang M, Gaschen B, Blay W, Foley B, Haigwood N, Kuiken C, Korber B: Tracking global patterns of N-linked glycosylation site variation in highly variable viral glycoproteins: HIV, SIV, and HCV envelopes and influenza hemagglutinin. Glycobiology. 2004, 14: 1229-1246.
Posada D, Crandall KA: Modeltest: testing the model of DNA substitution. Bioinformatics. 1998, 14: 817-818.
Wilgenbusch JC, Swofford D: Inferring evolutionary trees with PAUP*. Curr Protoc Bioinformatics. 2003, 6.4.1-6.4.28.
Hasegawa M, Kishino H, Yano T: Dating of the human-ape splitting by a molecular clock of mitochondrial DNA. J Mol Evol. 1985, 22: 160-174.
Lambert JS, Mofenson LM, Fletcher CV, Moye J, Stiehm ER, Meyer WA, Nemo GJ, Mathieson BJ, Hirsch G, Sapan CV, et al: Safety and pharmacokinetics of hyperimmune anti-human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) immunoglobulin administered to HIV-infected pregnant women and their newborns. Pediatric AIDS Clinical Trials Group Protocol 185 Pharmacokinetic Study Group. J Infect Dis. 1997, 175: 283-291.
Tersmette M, Winkel IN, Groenink M, Gruters RA, Spence P, Saman E, van der Groen G, Miedema F, Huisman JG: Detection and subtyping of HIV-1 isolates with a panel of characterized monoclonal antibodies to HIV-p24 gag. Virology. 1989, 171: 149-155.
Edgar RC: MUSCLE: multiple sequence alignment with high accuracy and high throughput. Nucleic Acids Res. 2004, 32: 1792-1797.
Heringa J: Two strategies for sequence comparison: profile-preprocessed and secondary structure-induced multiple alignment. Comput Chem. 1999, 23: 341-364.
Larkin MA, Blackshields G, Brown NP, Chenna R, McGettigan PA, McWilliam H, Valentin F, Wallace IM, Wilm A, Lopez R, et al: Clustal W and Clustal X version 2.0. Bioinformatics. 2007, 23: 2947-2948.
Kwong PD, Wyatt R, Robinson J, Sweet RW, Sodroski J, Hendrickson WA: Structure of an HIV gp120 envelope glycoprotein in complex with the CD4 receptor and a neutralizing human antibody. Nature. 1998, 393: 648-659.
Huang CC, Tang M, Zhang MY, Majeed S, Montabana E, Stanfield RL, Dimitrov DS, Korber B, Sodroski J, Wilson IA, et al: Structure of a V3-containing HIV-1 gp120 core. Science. 2005, 310: 1025-1028.
The Amsterdam Cohort Studies on HIV infection and AIDS, a collaboration between the Amsterdam Health Service, the Academic Medical Center of the University of Amsterdam, Sanquin Blood Supply Foundation, the University Medical Center Utrecht, and the Jan van Goyen Clinic, are part of The Netherlands HIV Monitoring Foundation and are financially supported by the Center for Infectious Disease Control of The Netherlands National Institute for Public Health and the Environment. This study was financially supported by a Vici grant to HS from The Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (grant #918.66.628), a grant from the European Community’s Sixth Framework Program “European HIV Enterprise (EUROPRISE)” (FP6/2007–2012), under grant agreement 037611, and the European Community’s Seventh Framework Program “Next-Generation HIV-1 Immunogens Inducing Broadly Reactive Neutralizing Antibodies (NGIN)” (FP7/2007–2013), under grant agreement 201433. RWS is a recipient of a Vidi grant from the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (grant #917.11.314) and a Starting Investigator Grant from the European Research Council (ERC-StG-2011-280829-SHEV). KAF receives financial support through the BioRange programme of the Netherlands Bioinformatics Centre (NBIC), which is supported by a BSIK grant through the Netherlands Genomics Initiative (NGI). The reagents IgG1 b12 (EVA3065), 2G12 (ARP3227), 2F5 (EVA3063), 4E10 (ARP3239) and 447-52D (ARP3219) were obtained from the Centre for AIDS Reagents, NIBSC HPA UK, supported by the EC FP6/7 Europrise Network of Excellence, and NGIN consortia and the Bill and Melinda Gates GHRC-CAVD Project and were donated by respectively Dr. D. P. Burton and Dr. P. Parren (The Scripps Research Institute, La Jolla, CA), Dr. D. Katinger (Polymun Scientific GmbH, Austria; as a partner in EUROPRISE) and Dr. S. Zolla-Pazner (New York University Medical Center, New York, NY). The following reagents were obtained through the AIDS Research and Reference Reagent Program, Division of AIDS, NIAID, NIH: Catalog #3957, HIV-IG from NABI and NHLBI; catalog #12033, HIV-1 gp120 MAb VRC01 from Dr. J Mascola; catalog #12149, HIV MAb PG9 from IAVI; and catalog #12150, HIV MAb PG16 from IAVI.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
TLGMK and BDB performed the experiments and together with KAF, LWER and RWS contributed to data acquisition. TLGMK, KAF, LWER and RWS analyzed the data. TLGMK, KAF, ZE, MJG, JH, RWS and HS conceived and designed the study and experiments. TLGMK and RWS wrote and TLGMK, KAF, ZE, MJG, LWER, JH, HS, RWS edited the paper. All authors have read and approved the final manuscript.
Electronic supplementary material
Additional file 1: Figure S1: Title of data: Baseline characteristics for the individuals with non-CrNA, intermediate CrNA and CrNA. Description of the data: (A) time, in months, between SC and CrNA level measured by Monogram Biosciences; (B) time, in months, between SC and isolation of clonal viral variants; (C) CD4+ T cells/μl blood at set-point; (D) viral load, in log10, at set-point. Individuals with non-CrNA, intermediate CrNA and CrNA in their serum are represented by circles, squares and triangles, respectively. Each individual is represented by one symbol. (TIFF 244 KB)
Additional file 2: Figure S2: Title of data: Genetic relationships between viruses from individuals with diverse levels of CrNA in serum. Description of data: Complete gp160 sequences derived from 26 individuals with varying levels of CrNA in serum were aligned and a ML tree was constructed. Individuals with high, intermediate and low CrNA are indicated in red, blue or green, respectively. (TIFF 295 KB)
Additional file 3: Table S1: Title of data: Sequence Harmony results with consensus sequences. Description of data: The Sequence Harmony (SH) method ( and http://www.ibi.vu.nl/programs/seqharmwww) was used to analyze amino acid differences between the consensus env sequences of the twelve individuals who developed CrNA and the nine individuals who did not develop CrNA, for details see Methods. The SH algorithm is an entropy-based method, which detects positions within an alignment that display compositional differences in related protein sequences divided in two groups, and might therefore be linked to functional differences. In addition, an empirical Z-score is calculated, reflecting the significance of the SH-score obtained based on 100 random shuffling events of the sequences between the two groups. Cut-off scores were set as SH<0.7 for the residues in the variable regions and <0.85 for residues in the conserved regions, i.e. a less strict selection in the conserved region to allow also small(er) differences to be detected. The lower (negative) the z-score, the less likely that the results were found by chance. (DOCX 352 KB)
Additional file 4: Figure S3: Title of data: Multiple sequence alignment of gp160 sequences from CrNA and non- CrNA individuals used for SH analysis. Description of data: Multiple sequence alignment of 91 complete gp160 sequences from 21 individuals, starting at nucleotide position 91, excluding the Env signal peptide, with a minimum of one and a maximum of eleven sequences per individual. In total 58 sequences from twelve individuals who developed CrNA and 33 sequences from nine individuals that did not develop CrNA, CrNA and non-CrNA respectively, are depicted. (TIFF 138 KB)
Additional file 5: Table S2: Title of data: Subclustering of positions identified by SH. Description of data: Six sites are isolated in the structure (and sequence) and form a cluster of their own. Three small clusters are purely sequential. Another sequential cluster (T138, N139, T140, N141, S142) is not present in any of the crystal structures analyzed, but aligns with a similar region (T138→T135, N139→I136, N141→N137 in 3U4E) which makes it cluster with another residue (K151 at 4Å). Finally, there are four other clusters containing sequentially distant residues with on average slightly more than four residues per cluster. In one case this clustering is tight, with a distance around 3Å, the three other distances involved are around 6-7Å. One of these clusters consists of three sequential parts and involves one tight and one looser distance. Most clusters are restricted to within one of the V or C regions, except for the one that connects C1 and C2, and the two others that bridge C3 and V4. Almost all residues selected within the V4 region are in close contact with the α2-helix (336–353) of the C3 region. (XLSX 14 KB)
Additional file 6: Table S3: Title of data: Median neutralization IC50 titer per individual per bNAb. Description of data: Median neutralization IC50 titer of the primary HIV-1 variants from 21 selected individuals to neutralization by eleven different bNAbs covering the four known epitope clusters, namely CD4BS (b12 and VRC01), gp120 outer domain (447-52D, 2G12, PGT121 and PGT126), quaternary V1V2 (PG9, PG16 and PGT145) and MPER (2F5 and 4E10), and to the three polyclonal HIVIg pools. Interestingly, early HIV-1 variants of individuals who developed CrNA were more sensitive to neutralization by polyclonal HIVIg pool 1 compared to early viruses from individuals who did not develop CrNA (p = 0.037), although this was found for the other two pools tested. (XLSX 11 KB)
Additional file 7: Figure S4: Title of data: Correlation of SH-scores and Z-scores. Description of data: (A) Correlation of the SH scores as found by Sequence Harmony; (B) Correlation of the Z-scores found by Sequence Harmony. Each amino acid difference in Env between individuals who did or did not developed CrNA is represented by one dot. The value on the x-axis represents scores found when using 91 Env sequences as described in Materials, and the value on the y-axis represents the scores found when using the consensus sequences of the 12 individuals who did and the 9 individuals who did not developed CrNA. Statistical analyses on the SH-scores and the Z-scores were performed using Graphpad Prism v5.01. Correlations between the two methods were compared using a Pearson correlation test. Differences and correlations were considered statistically significant when P values were ≤ 0.05. (XLSX 17 KB)
About this article
Cite this article
van den Kerkhof, T.L.G.M., Feenstra, K.A., Euler, Z. et al. HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein signatures that correlate with the development of cross-reactive neutralizing activity. Retrovirology 10, 102 (2013). https://doi.org/10.1186/1742-4690-10-102
- Early HIV-1 variants
- Envelope glycoprotein
- Cross-reactive neutralizing activity
- Broadly reactive neutralizing antibodies