- Short report
- Open Access
Ethnic differences in the adaptation rate of HIV gp120 from a vaccine trial
Retrovirology volume 6, Article number: 67 (2009)
Differences in HIV-1 gp120 sequence variation were examined in North American volunteers who became infected during a phase III vaccine trial using the rgp120 vaccine. Molecular adaptation of the virus in vaccine and placebo recipients from different ethnic subgroups was compared by estimating the dN/dS ratios in viruses sampled from each individual using three different methods. ANOVA analyses detected significant differences in dN/dS ratios among races (P < 0.02). gp120 sequences from the black individuals showed higher mean dN/dS ratios for all estimators (1.24–1.45) than in other races (0.66–1.35), and several pairwise comparisons involving blacks remained significant (P < 0.05) after correction for multiple tests. In addition, black-placebo individuals showed significantly (P < 0.02) higher mean dN/dS ratios (1.3–1.66) than placebo individuals from the other races (0.65–1.56). These results suggest intrinsic differences among races in immune response and highlight the need for including multiple ethnicities in the design of future HIV-1 vaccine studies and trials.
More than 33 million people are currently infected with HIV-1, resulting in 2–3 million deaths every year. Natural immunity to the virus is virtually nonexistent; hence, the creation of a vaccine to combat this global pandemic is an international public-health priority [1, 2]. In 2003, the results were released for a phase III HIV-1 vaccine efficacy trial conducted in North America and The Netherlands (VAX004) . This study tested the efficacy of bivalent vaccines containing recombinant HIV-1 envelope glycoprotein 120 (rgp120) antigens, the major antigen on the surface of the virus . Overall, the vaccine candidate did not seem to reduce the incidence of HIV-1 infection, but an interesting trend was noted in the analysis of the different self-described ethnic groups [white (non-Hispanic), blacks, Hispanic, Asian, and "others"]. When only the non-white volunteers (17% of the total study population) were considered, the vaccine seemed to confer a slight benefit (P = 0.012). After adjustment for multiple tests, this difference was not significant (P = 0.13) . Despite a lack of statistical support, this is not a trivial result. If this trend was to be confirmed, it would imply that non-whites developed protective immunity to HIV-1 or, even more important, that rgp120 immunogens could protect against HIV infection under certain circumstances. Here we explored this possibility further.
HIV-1 evolution is driven, to a significant extent, by the immune response. If viruses isolated from non-white patients are in fact under a stronger selection pressure either because of genetic differences in the magnitude, specificity, or potency of the natural immune response, or because of differences in factors affecting virus replication, we should expect higher ratios of nonsynonymous (amino acid changing) to synonymous nucleotide substitutions (dN/dS) [5–8] than in viral samples isolated from vaccinated and placebo (non-vaccinated) white individuals.
To test whether levels of selection were significantly different between vaccinated and placebo individuals in different races, we analyzed 3 clones per individual from 345 infected North Americans from the VAX004 study (Table 1; data available at http://www.gsid.org). Full-length HIV-1 subtype B gp120 sequences were amplified as described in Gilbert et al. . Since, as expected, viruses isolated from individuals from the same race did not form monophyletic groups , viral samples for each patient were analyzed separately. In each case, individual clones were aligned in MAFFT v5.7 , and dN/dS ratios were estimated using Nei and Gojobori's method  in SNAP , model M0 (one-ratio) in PAML v3.14 , and Fixed Effects Likelihood (FEL) with tree branch correction in HYPHY . In the latter case, we took recombination into account by first detecting recombination breakpoints with GARD , and then estimating the dN/dS ratios independently for each fragment.
Mean dN/dS ratios across races and treatments were compared using ANOVA, linear models (lm) and pairwise t-tests. Because treating all non-whites as a single unit is unrealistic considering their own genetic differences , we tested for differences in selection pressure on a race-by-race basis. Multiple significance in the pairwise t-tests was corrected using the Benjamini and Hochberg's procedure .
The estimates of dN/dS obtained with SNAP, PAML and HYPHY were all significantly correlated among the different estimators used (correlation coefficient > 0.85; P < 0.001). Importantly, the mean dN/dS ratios varied across races (Table 1), and these differences were globally significant (ANOVA;P < 0.02) for SNAP and PAML estimates. Blacks (vaccinees and placebo combined) showed higher dN/dS ratios for all the estimators than individuals from other ethnicities (Table 1). Significant differences (pairwise t-tests; P < 0.05) between black and white, Hispanic and "others" viral samples were observed for all the estimators before corrections, but only the comparisons involving SNAP and PAML estimates remained significant after the Benjamini and Hochberg's adjustment (Table 2). The higher dN/dS ratios observed for blacks suggest that the rate of virus evolution is greater in this group than in other volunteers. Differences in immune response to HIV-1 infection have been pointed out by the rgp120 HIV Vaccine Study Group  as one of the potential factors to explain vaccine efficiency differences between white and non-white volunteers in the VAX004 trial. Ethnic differences in immune response have been also reported for other viruses such as the hepatitis C virus .
Does the greater virus adaptive variation presumed in black participants reflect genetic differences in the intrinsic (no-preconditioned) immune response to HIV-1, or is it a consequence of the conditioned immune response induced by vaccination with rgp120? Comparison of vaccine and placebo recipients showed different results based on the dN/dS estimators used. No significant differences were observed among vaccinees, but significant differences (ANOVA; P = 0.025) in SNAP dN/dS ratios were detected among placebo individuals. Moreover, black-placebo patients showed significantly (lm coefficients; P < 0.02) higher mean dN/dS ratios (1.3, 1.38 and 1.66, for SNAP, PAML and HYPHY, respectively) than the other races (0.65–1.01, 0.84–1.14 and 0.73–1.56, respectively). These results might indicate that natural differences in the immune response may have increased viral rgp120 adaptation in blacks.
In North America, blacks correspond to 42% of all newly diagnosed HIV/AIDS cases, while white (non-Hispanic) and Hispanic individuals represent approximately 40% and 17%, respectively . If more data including both placebo and vaccinated recipients confirm that selection pressure differs between viruses infecting these three races, deciphering the genetic determinants of these differences should become a public-health priority. Indeed, our results highlight the need for selecting a broader representation of volunteers, based on ethnicity, in the design of future HIV-1 vaccine studies and trials .
Esparza J, Bhamarapravati N: Accelerating the development and future availability of HIV-1 vaccines: why, when, where, and how?. Lancet. 2000, 355: 2061-2066. 10.1016/S0140-6736(00)02360-6.
Spearman P: HIV vaccine development: lessons from the past and promise for the future. Curr HIV Res. 2003, 1: 101-120. 10.2174/1570162033352093.
rgp120 HIV Vaccine Study Group: Placebo controlled phase 3 trial of a recombinant glycoprotein 120 vaccine to prevent HIV-1 infection. rgp120 HIV Vaccine Study Group. J Infect Dis. 2005, 191: 654-665. 10.1086/428404.
Eggink D, Melchers M, Sanders RW: Antibodies to HIV-1: aiming at the right target. Trends Microbiol. 2007, 15: 291-294. 10.1016/j.tim.2007.05.006.
Sharp PM: In search of molecular Darwinism. Nature. 1997, 385: 111-112. 10.1038/385111a0.
Nei M, Gojobori T: Simple methods for estimating the numbers of synonymous and nonsynonymous nucleotide substitutions. Mol Biol Evol. 1986, 3: 418-426.
Ross HA, Rodrigo AG: Immune-mediated positive selection drives human immunodeficiency virus type 1 molecular variation and predicts disease duration. J Virol. 2002, 76: 11715-11720. 10.1128/JVI.76.22.11715-11720.2002.
Williamson S: Adaptation in the env gene of HIV-1 and evolutionary theories of disease progression. Mol Biol Evol. 2003, 20: 1318-1325. 10.1093/molbev/msg144.
Gilbert PB, Peterson ML, Follmann D, Hudgens MG, Francis DP, Gurwith M, Heyward WL, Jobes DV, Popovic V, Self SG, et al: Correlation between immunologic responses to a recombinant glycoprotein 120 vaccine and incidence of HIV-1 infection in a phase 3 HIV-1 preventive vaccine trial. J Infect Dis. 2005, 191: 666-677. 10.1086/428405.
Pérez-Losada M, Jobes DV, Sinangil F, Crandall KA, Posada D, Berman PW: Phylodynamics of gp120 sequences from a Phase 3 HIV-1 vaccine trial in North America. Mol Biol Evol. 2009, in review
Katoh K, Kuma K, Toh H, Miyata T: MAFFT version 5: improvement in accuracy of multiple sequence alignment. Nucleic Acids Res. 2005, 33: 511-518. 10.1093/nar/gki198.
Korber B: HIV signature and sequence variation analysis. Computational and evolutionary analysis of HIV molecular sequences. Edited by: Rodrigo AG, Learn GH. 2000, Dordrecht, Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 4: 55-72.
Yang Z: PAML: Phylogenetic Analysis by Maximum Likelihood. 2001, London: University College London, 3.1
Kosakovsky Pond SL, Frost SDW, Muse SV: HyPhy: hypothesis testing using phylogenies. Bioinformatics. 2005, 21: 676-679. 10.1093/bioinformatics/bti079.
Kosakovsky Pond SL, Posada D, Gravenor MB, Woelk CH, Frost SD: GARD: a genetic algorithm for recombination detection. Bioinformatics. 2006, 22: 3096-3098. 10.1093/bioinformatics/btl474.
Benjamini Y, Hochberg Y: Controlling the false discovery rate: a practical and powerful approach to multiple testing. J R Statist Soc B. 1995, 57: 289-300.
Sugimoto K, Stadanlick J, Ikeda F, Brensinger C, Furth EE, Alter HJ, Chang KM: Influence of ethnicity in the outcome of hepatitis C virus infection and cellular immune response. Hepatology. 2003, 37: 590-599. 10.1053/jhep.2003.50103.
CDC: HIV/AIDS Surveillance Report. 2007, Atlanta: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 19:
Graham BS, Mascola JR: Lessons from failure – preparing for future HIV-1 vaccine efficacy trials. J Infect Dis. 2005, 191: 647-649. 10.1086/428406.
This study was supported by a Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation grant to Global Solutions for Infectious Diseases. It was also supported by the Spanish Ministry of Science and Education [grant number BIO2007-61411 to DP, FPI fellowship BES-2005-9151 to MA]. We also want to thank the reviewers for their excellent suggestions.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
MPL, DP, and KC developed the genetic and statistical strategies implemented in this work. MPL, DP, and MA performed the genetic and statistical analyses. DVJ, FS, and PWB carried out the molecular genetic studies and immunoassays. All authors participated in the design of the study and helped to draft the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Rights and permissions
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
About this article
Cite this article
Pérez-Losada, M., Posada, D., Arenas, M. et al. Ethnic differences in the adaptation rate of HIV gp120 from a vaccine trial. Retrovirology 6, 67 (2009). https://doi.org/10.1186/1742-4690-6-67
- Viral Sample
- Gp120 Sequence
- Synonymous Nucleotide Substitution
- Natural Immune Response
- Vaccine Efficacy Trial